So this happened, and it’s open season for games journalism now

Geoff Keighley appeared in an interview with PixelPerfectMag on YouTube and talked a little bit about some upcoming games…especially Halo 4 and its partner programs with Mountain Dew and Doritos. And boy did Mountain Dew and Doritos get some play. Now, there’s nothing wrong with sponsorship in gaming, but that should be between the video game publisher and the product maker. When gaming journalists step in and decide to take part in that relationship, everybody is going to cry foul.

I don’t have any doubts about Geoff Keighley’s ability to do his job well. I don’t think he’s been dishonest in the past, but when you see him, or anybody else for that matter, sitting in a room surrounded by promotional material, it’s not a stretch to start thinking that their viewpoint might begin to skew in favor of those sponsors just a little bit. Take a look at the video below, and I’ll give my reaction and explain why this could have been approached in a much better way.

[embedplusvideo height="356" width="584" standard="http://www.youtube.com/v/sjXSI6O9lUo?fs=1" vars="ytid=sjXSI6O9lUo&width=584&height=356&start=&stop=&rs=w&hd=0&autoplay=0&react=0&chapters=&notes=" id="ep8688" /]

Geoff is seated around a bunch of promotional material. That’s the first and last thing you’ll notice when watching this clip. It looks bad. The thing is, if Geoff agreed to talk about the Dew/Doritos XP program, that’s fine, but they shouldn’t have disguised it as a simple interview. They should have presented it as a sponsored segment. Secondly, it could have been presented in a more detached manner. Remove the marketing materials. All they’re doing is evoking thoughts of Wayne’s World’s sellout bit. They look cheap and forced. Talk about the program, be upfront that a deal has been made to promote it, and don’t try and act like you’re just interested in talking about Mountain Dew and Doritos because they’re such fine products.

When talking about Halo 4 or the Dew XP program, all Geoff would have said to make this go down easier would have been, “and I want to talk about this DewXP and Halo 4 stuff. I’ve been lucky enough to be asked by Mountain Dew and 343 Industries to discuss it with you.” Doing that, it would have been received so much better. By disguising it as a journalistic segment between an online magazine and a journalist, this whole segment comes across as gross, insulting, and kind of sad.

Let’s not move this direction, people. Let’s learn from this misstep and separate coverage from promotion with clear, bold lines. When we neglect to do so, especially with a respected member of the games journalism community, the reactions that arise are damaging to our industry and to our attempts to be taken seriously by the gamer community.

5 thoughts on “So this happened, and it’s open season for games journalism now

  1. I’m comparing cost of living to other parts in SC. I want to increase our joint savings. I’m not as concerned about the student loans and car. “George W. Bush may God forgive me because I knew his parents really well. I didn’t realise until later that I wasn’t going to support him any more.”.It is NEVER about your sexual organs, but always about light and vessel. That God made it so that some people would be “female” (gentle and healing) and “male” (passionate and fierce). He reckons this is how people fit together. 19, 2014, for Michael Brown, who was killed by police Aug. 9 in Ferguson, Mo. Ferguson’s leaders urged residents Tuesday to stay home after dark to “allow peace to settle in” and pledged several actions to reconnect with the predominantly black community in the St.
    Jordan 11 Legend Blue http://www.yamagatadsa.com/css/LegendBlue11ss/

  2. He then worked for the commission in Ruthven.In 1986, he came back to his hometown of Mason City as a naturalist and became conservation director in 1990.”The work has changed a lot in the past 35 years,” said Heinz. “There used to be a slower time of the year, but not any more. It’s pretty much the same pace seven days a week, 365 days a year.”Ron Masters, a Conservation Board member for more than 30 years, said Heinz’s dedication to conservation is boundless.”He’s a very sensitive individual and his sensitivity drives him to do things that are right,” said Masters.
    Legend Blue 11s http://www.nirvanaspajordan.com/DyImages/LegendBlue11s/

  3. In his campaign, Obama promised not to increase taxes but just by letting the Bush tax cuts expire, he will in effect be raising taxes. Gotcha, HE won’t raise taxes, he’ll just let other tax cuts expire. You’ll owe uncle same more money, but Obama won’t be raising that tax at that time..
    jordan 13 barons http://www.saudigec.com/partss.php

  4. The main Latino girl then explains that there is no other place for them, promoting the idea that the students have nobody to talk to about their problems or find any comfort in their lives. Showing the deeper problem of these students rather than failing grades and gang violence. The problem stated in this trailer is that the students feel like they are powerless to the world around them.”Once the emotion is there, it would be far worse if my girlfriend continued with the kiss, than if it was just a random pash in a club,” he explained. He then thought about it for a while and seemed to backpedal from his theory. “Although kissing a random guy in a club would be pretty bad too,” he added..
    jordan outlet http://www.hcinnovation.org/changess.php

  5. L de la l de la unilat d du Kosovo par la Cour internationale de Justice (CIJ), le Pr serbe a insist sur le fait que les conclusions de la Cour, qui seront transmises prochainement l g auront des cons directes sur l du syst des Nations Unies. Toute question relative au Kosovo porte, a t il dit, de pr ou de loin sur celle du statut. LAMBERTO ZANNIER, Repr sp du Secr g et Chef de la Mission int des Nations Unies au Kosovo (MINUK), a tout d apport des pr sur l qui s produit vendredi, 2 juillet, dans la partie nord de Mitrovica.
    jordan 13 barons http://www.ubcontinentalhotel.com/contentss.php

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>